I've always wanted to hear STRICTLY PERSONAL by Captain Beefheart and
the Magic Band in its elusive mono mix, and now - after winning a copy
of the first UK pressing - I've finally had the pleasure.
It was not
what I expected, and not fully what I'd heard described; I'd read that
it was a more powerful mix, the "truer" mix, if you will. But it sounds
to my ears, unusually, like Bob Krasnow's stereo mix came first and that
the mono version is a compression of that. It's usually
the other way around with albums of this vintage, but stereo was
becoming standardized by 1968 with some important albums (like Jefferson
Airplane's CROWN OF CREATION) not even receiving a mono release.
The
album's controversial phasing is still in evidence, it just doesn't
travel anywhere, except maybe up and down along the Human Totem Pole.
Some elements buried in the hectic stereo mix - cymbals, bass,
background vocals - are squeezed closer to the fore, and so can be heard
more clearly, while other instrumentation collides in its compression
into a shambolic miasma of sound.
I need to spend more time with it.
After one listen, I'm not sure that I don't prefer the stereo mix.